Pet Insurance Guide: What's Covered, What's Not & How to Choose (2025)

With the average emergency vet visit costing between $800 to $1,500 and complex treatments like cancer therapy potentially exceeding $10,000, pet insurance has become an essential consideration for responsible pet owners. Yet understanding exactly what pet insurance covers—and perhaps more importantly, what it doesn’t—remains confusing for many.

In this comprehensive guide, we’ll navigate the sometimes complex world of pet insurance coverage, from policy types and common exclusions to real-world claim examples. Whether you’re considering pet insurance for the first time or reviewing your current coverage, this article will help you make an informed decision that best protects both your pet and your finances.

Understanding the Basics of Pet Insurance Coverage

Before diving into specific coverage details, it’s important to understand the fundamental structure of pet insurance and how it differs from human health insurance.

How Pet Insurance Works Differently from Human Health Insurance

Unlike human health insurance, pet insurance generally operates on a reimbursement model:

You pay the veterinarian directly at the time of service
You submit a claim to your insurance provider with documentation
The provider reviews the claim against your policy coverage
If approved, you receive reimbursement based on your policy terms

This means you’ll need to have the financial resources to cover veterinary costs upfront, even with insurance. Some newer providers are beginning to offer direct payment to veterinarians, but this is still relatively uncommon.

Another key difference is that pet insurance doesn’t typically involve networks—you can generally visit any licensed veterinarian, specialist, or emergency clinic of your choice.

The Three Main Types of Coverage

Pet insurance policies typically fall into three broad categories:

Accident-Only Coverage:

Covers injuries resulting from accidents (broken bones, lacerations, ingestion of foreign objects, etc.)
Typically the most affordable option
Doesn’t cover any illness-related conditions
Usually has fewer exclusions than more comprehensive plans

Illness Coverage:

Covers diseases, infections, and sicknesses
May be offered as standalone or combined with accident coverage
Often includes coverage for chronic conditions, cancer, and hereditary issues
Usually more expensive than accident-only plans

Comprehensive Coverage:

Combines accident and illness coverage in one policy
The most extensive protection available
Often allows for optional wellness care add-ons
The highest premium option, but provides the most complete coverage

According to the North American Pet Health Insurance Association, approximately 98% of insured pets in the US have combined accident and illness coverage, making it the most popular choice among pet owners.

Key Terms You Need to Know

Understanding these essential insurance terms will help you better evaluate and compare policies:

Deductible: The amount you must pay before insurance coverage begins. This can be annual (paid once per policy year regardless of the number of claims) or per-incident (paid for each separate condition or incident).

Reimbursement Percentage: The portion of the covered expenses the insurer will pay after your deductible is met. Common options are 70%, 80%, and 90%, though some providers offer up to 100% reimbursement.

Annual Limit: The maximum amount the policy will pay within a 12-month period. Options typically range from $5,000 to unlimited.

Premium: The amount you pay (monthly or annually) to maintain your insurance policy.

Waiting Period: The time between policy enrollment and when coverage takes effect. This typically ranges from 48 hours for accidents to 14-30 days for illnesses, with longer periods for certain conditions like cruciate ligament issues.

Exclusions: Specific conditions, treatments, or circumstances that are not covered by the policy.

What Pet Insurance Typically Covers

While coverage varies by provider and plan, most comprehensive pet insurance policies will cover the following:

Accident Coverage

Accident coverage typically includes:

Injuries from accidents (broken bones, cuts, punctures)
Foreign object ingestion
Toxic ingestion and poisoning
Vehicle accidents
Falls and other physical injuries
Animal bites and attack injuries
Torn ligaments and sprains from activity

Most accident coverage takes effect after a short waiting period of 24-48 hours following enrollment.

Illness Coverage

Illness coverage typically includes:

Infections and infectious diseases
Digestive issues
Respiratory conditions
Cancer and tumors
Diabetes and endocrine disorders
Heart and cardiovascular conditions
Skin conditions and allergies
Eye and ear infections
Urinary tract infections

Many policies will cover chronic conditions as long as they weren’t pre-existing before enrollment and the policy remains in force continuously.

Diagnostic Testing and Imaging

Most comprehensive plans cover diagnostic procedures necessary to identify conditions, including:

Blood tests and lab work
X-rays
Ultrasounds
MRIs and CT scans
Biopsies
Urinalysis and fecal exams
Endoscopy
Electrocardiograms

Diagnostic testing is typically covered when it’s related to a covered accident or illness, rather than as routine preventive care (unless you have a wellness rider).

Surgeries and Hospitalizations

Covered surgical and hospital treatments generally include:

Emergency surgeries
Specialist surgical procedures
Overnight hospital stays
Nursing care during hospitalization
IV fluids and medications while hospitalized
Oxygen therapy
Monitoring during hospitalization
Post-surgical care

These services often represent the highest potential veterinary expenses, making them particularly valuable components of pet insurance coverage.

Medications and Prescribed Treatments

Most comprehensive policies cover:

Prescription medications
Antibiotics
Pain management drugs
Chemotherapy medications
Insulin and diabetes management drugs
Injectable medications
Prescription diets (with some plans or riders)
Some specialized treatments like stem cell therapy (varies by policy)

Coverage for medications typically applies to those prescribed for covered conditions rather than preventive medications like flea, tick, and heartworm preventatives (though these may be covered with wellness riders).

Common Exclusions and Limitations

Understanding what isn’t covered is just as important as knowing what is. Here are the most common exclusions in pet insurance policies:

Pre-Existing Conditions (How They’re Defined and Handled)

Pre-existing conditions are typically defined as any illness or injury that showed symptoms before your policy’s effective date or during waiting periods. These conditions are universally excluded from coverage.

However, providers differ in how they handle pre-existing conditions:

Some distinguish between curable and incurable pre-existing conditions, potentially reinstating coverage for curable conditions after a certain symptom-free period (typically 6-12 months)
Others maintain permanent exclusions for any pre-existing condition
Most will review medical records to identify pre-existing conditions during the claims process
Conditions that develop after coverage begins are generally covered, even if they’re hereditary or congenital issues

This exclusion is the primary reason to insure pets when they’re young and healthy, before they develop chronic conditions.

Waiting Periods and Their Implications

All pet insurance policies impose waiting periods—timeframes between enrollment and when coverage begins:

Accident waiting periods: Typically 2-14 days
Illness waiting periods: Usually 14-30 days
Orthopedic conditions (especially cruciate ligament issues): Often 6-12 months

Any condition that arises during these waiting periods will be considered pre-existing and excluded from coverage. These periods prevent people from enrolling only after a pet becomes sick or injured.

Breed-Specific Exclusions

Some policies may have exclusions or limitations for conditions that are prevalent in certain breeds:

Respiratory issues in brachycephalic (flat-faced) breeds like Bulldogs and Pugs
Hip dysplasia in large breeds like German Shepherds and Labrador Retrievers
Patellar luxation in small breeds like Pomeranians and Chihuahuas
Heart conditions in Cavalier King Charles Spaniels
Intervertebral disc disease in Dachshunds

These exclusions vary significantly by provider. Some insurers charge higher premiums for these breeds, while others may exclude specific conditions or impose longer waiting periods.

Routine and Wellness Care (Unless Added)

Standard pet insurance policies typically exclude:

Routine examinations
Preventive vaccinations
Dental cleanings
Spay/neuter procedures
Flea, tick, and heartworm prevention
Grooming
Microchipping
Routine blood work

Many providers offer wellness riders or preventive care packages as optional add-ons to cover these services, usually for an additional premium.

Behavioral Therapy and Training

Most standard policies exclude:

Behavioral consultations and therapy
Training classes
Treatment for behavioral issues like anxiety, aggression, or destructive behaviors
Medications specifically for behavioral concerns

Some premium plans or specialized riders may cover medically necessary behavioral treatments prescribed by veterinarians, but general training and behavioral modification typically remain excluded.

Alternative Treatments (Varies by Provider)

Coverage for alternative and complementary therapies varies widely:

Acupuncture
Chiropractic care
Hydrotherapy
Laser therapy
Rehabilitation therapy
Herbal medicine
Homeopathy

Some providers include these treatments in their standard policies, while others offer them as optional add-ons or exclude them entirely. If alternative treatments are important to you, carefully check the policy details before enrolling.

Optional Coverage Add-Ons Worth Considering

Many pet insurance providers offer optional riders or add-ons that can expand your coverage beyond the standard policy. Here’s what to know about the most common options:

Wellness and Preventative Care Riders

Wellness riders typically cover routine care that helps prevent illness and maintain health:

Annual wellness exams
Vaccinations
Parasite prevention (flea, tick, heartworm)
Routine blood work and health screenings
Urinalysis and fecal testing
Microchipping

These plans usually work as scheduled benefits, providing specific allowances for each covered service up to annual maximums. Some providers structure these as “use it or lose it” benefits, meaning unused allowances don’t roll over.

While wellness add-ons increase your premium, they can provide value if you’re diligent about preventative care. The typical cost ranges from $10-30 monthly depending on the level of coverage.

Dental Coverage Options

Dental care can represent a significant expense, with comprehensive cleanings often costing $300-1,000 depending on your location and your pet’s needs. Dental add-ons typically cover:

Annual or bi-annual dental cleanings
Dental X-rays
Extractions of diseased teeth
Treatment for periodontal disease
Some coverage for dental injuries and diseases

Standard accident and illness policies may cover dental injuries from trauma but usually exclude routine dental care and disease unless you add a specific dental rider. Since dental disease affects over 80% of dogs and 70% of cats over age three, this coverage can be particularly valuable.

Prescription Food and Supplements

Therapeutic diets and supplements are commonly prescribed for conditions like:

Kidney disease
Food allergies
Gastrointestinal disorders
Diabetes management
Weight management
Joint support

Standard policies typically exclude prescription diets, but some providers offer nutrition riders that provide coverage for veterinarian-prescribed foods and supplements. These riders usually have specific annual or per-condition limits and may require documentation that the diet is medically necessary rather than preventative.

End-of-Life and Euthanasia Coverage

This sensitive but important coverage typically includes:

Euthanasia procedures
Cremation or burial services
End-of-life hospice and palliative care
Some memorial expenses

Many standard policies include euthanasia if it’s deemed medically necessary but may exclude cremation/burial services. Specific end-of-life riders expand this coverage to include aftercare services as well. While difficult to consider, this coverage can provide financial relief during an already emotionally challenging time.

Boarding Fees During Owner’s Hospitalization

This unique coverage helps with pet care when you’re unable to provide it due to your own medical emergency:

Kennel or boarding facility fees if you’re hospitalized
Sometimes covers in-home pet sitting services
Usually has specific daily and annual maximums
Typically requires a minimum hospitalization period (often 48+ hours)

This add-on provides peace of mind that your pet will be cared for during unexpected personal medical situations. Some premium comprehensive plans include this coverage automatically, while others offer it as an optional add-on.

Top Pet Insurance Providers Compared

After analyzing dozens of providers, we’ve identified the standouts in various categories. Here’s how they compare:

Best Overall Coverage: Healthy Paws

Healthy Paws consistently ranks as a top provider for comprehensive coverage:

No caps on claim payouts (unlimited annual and lifetime benefits)
Covers hereditary and congenital conditions
Includes alternative therapies
Simple, easy-to-understand policies with few exclusions
Generally fast claims processing (often within 2-10 days)
Covers emergency care, hospitalization, specialty care, and chronic conditions

The main drawbacks include no wellness coverage options and age-based restrictions on coverage options and reimbursement levels for senior pets.

Click here to get a personalized quote from Healthy Paws

Best for Customizable Plans: Embrace

Embrace stands out for its highly customizable coverage options:

Flexibility to adjust deductibles, reimbursement percentages, and annual limits
Diminishing deductibles that decrease by $50 each year you don’t file a claim
Comprehensive accident and illness coverage
Optional wellness rewards program
Coverage for exam fees (which many providers exclude)
Covers behavioral therapy and training
Curable pre-existing conditions may be covered after 12 months symptom-free

Potential drawbacks include annual limits (no unlimited option) and slightly higher than average premiums for the most comprehensive coverage.

Best for Older Pets: Pets Best

Pets Best distinguishes itself with senior-friendly policies:

No upper age limits for enrollment
Specific plans designed for senior pet needs
Direct veterinarian payment option available
Relatively affordable options for older pets
Quick claims processing
Optional wellness and routine care coverage
24/7 veterinary helpline included with all plans

The main limitations include per-incident limits on some plans and potentially higher premiums for certain breeds with known health issues.

Best for Multiple Pets: ASPCA Pet Health Insurance

ASPCA Pet Health Insurance offers advantages for multi-pet households:

10% discount for each additional pet
Comprehensive coverage options
Coverage for hereditary and congenital conditions
No networks—use any licensed veterinarian
Optional preventive care coverage
Coverage for behavioral issues and microchip implantation
User-friendly mobile app for claims submission

Potential drawbacks include annual limits (no unlimited option) and waiting periods that are slightly longer than some competitors.

Click here to see multi-pet discount options from ASPCA Pet Health Insurance

Best for Exotic Pets: Nationwide

Nationwide stands out as one of the few major providers covering exotic pets:

Coverage for birds, reptiles, small mammals, and amphibians
Comprehensive policies for dogs and cats also available
Wellness coverage option
Coverage for hereditary conditions
Offers both scheduled benefit plans and percentage reimbursement options
Long-established company with extensive experience

Drawbacks include potentially longer claims processing times and higher premiums for certain exotic species. Their scheduled benefit plans may also reimburse less than percent-based plans for high-cost treatments.

Best Budget Option: Lemonade

Lemonade offers surprisingly affordable coverage without sacrificing essential protection:

Policies starting as low as $10/month for some pets
User-friendly digital experience with fast claims processing
Customizable coverage options
Optional wellness and preventive care packages
Charitable component—unused premiums go to pet-related charities
Bundling discounts available with Lemonade’s other insurance products

The main limitations include being relatively new to the pet insurance market and not being available in all states. Their coverage for hereditary conditions may also be more limited than some premium providers.

How to Determine Your Pet’s Specific Coverage Needs

Not all pets have the same insurance needs. Here’s how to assess what coverage is right for your specific companion:

Assessing Breed-Specific Risks

Different breeds have different predispositions to health issues:

Dogs:

Large breeds (German Shepherds, Labrador Retrievers): Hip dysplasia, elbow dysplasia, bloat
Brachycephalic breeds (Bulldogs, Pugs): Respiratory issues, eye problems, dental disease
Dachshunds and long-backed breeds: Intervertebral disc disease
Deep-chested breeds (Great Danes, Dobermans): Cardiac issues, bloat
Retrievers and sporting breeds: Cancer, joint issues

Cats:

Persians and flat-faced breeds: Respiratory and eye issues
Maine Coons: Hypertrophic cardiomyopathy
Siamese: Respiratory and dental issues
Abyssinians: Progressive retinal atrophy
Domestic shorthairs: Generally fewer breed-specific issues

Research your pet’s breed-specific health risks and ensure your chosen policy doesn’t exclude conditions common to your pet’s breed. Some policies have specific exclusions or waiting periods for breed-associated conditions.

Your pet’s age significantly impacts both coverage needs and premium costs:

Puppies and Kittens (0-2 years):

Higher risk of accidents from curious behavior
Potential congenital issues emerging
Preventive care needs for vaccinations and spay/neuter
Lower premiums but consider policies that will grow with them

Adult Pets (2-7 years):

Balanced accident and illness coverage
Emerging chronic conditions become more common
Dental disease often develops
Moderate premium costs

Senior Pets (7+ years):

Increasing illness risk, especially chronic conditions
Reduced accident risk in most cases
Higher premium costs
More pre-existing condition exclusions
Some providers limit coverage options for seniors

For older pets, carefully review senior-specific restrictions. Some providers won’t issue new policies for pets above certain ages or limit coverage options. Wellness coverage becomes increasingly valuable for senior pets who need more frequent preventive care.

Lifestyle and Environment Factors

Your pet’s lifestyle and environment should influence your coverage choices:

Indoor vs. Outdoor Cats:

Indoor: Typically lower accident risk, more focus on illness coverage
Outdoor: Higher accident and injury risk, potential exposure to diseases

Active vs. Sedentary Dogs:

Active/athletic: Higher risk of orthopedic injuries, need solid accident coverage
Working dogs: Occupation-specific risks (police, search and rescue, hunting dogs)
Sedentary: Potentially higher risk of obesity-related conditions

Geographic Considerations:

Regional parasites and diseases (Lyme disease, heartworm, valley fever)
Urban environments: Traffic accidents, foreign body ingestion
Rural settings: Wildlife encounters, toxic plant exposure
Climate-related conditions (heat stroke in hot climates, hypothermia in cold regions)

Match your coverage to your pet’s actual lifestyle and risks rather than generic recommendations. For example, adventure dogs who hike and swim regularly benefit from robust accident coverage and emergency care.

Balancing Premium Costs vs. Coverage Levels

Finding the right balance between affordable premiums and appropriate coverage requires considering several factors:

Deductible Options:

Higher deductibles ($500-1,000): Lower monthly premiums, but more out-of-pocket costs before coverage kicks in
Lower deductibles ($100-250): Higher monthly premiums, but coverage begins sooner
Annual vs. per-incident deductibles: Annual generally provides better value for multiple claims

Reimbursement Percentages:

Lower percentages (70%): Lower premiums but more out-of-pocket with each claim
Higher percentages (90%): Higher premiums but less financial burden during claims

Annual Limits:

Lower limits ($5,000-10,000): More affordable premiums
Unlimited coverage: Higher premiums but better protection against catastrophic expenses

Financial Considerations:

Your emergency savings availability
Local veterinary costs in your area
Your comfort level with financial risk
Long-term affordability of premiums

The ideal balance varies for each pet owner. Consider what would be financially devastating versus merely inconvenient, and structure your coverage accordingly. Many experts recommend choosing the highest reimbursement percentage you can afford with a deductible that makes the premium manageable.

Real Claims Examples: What Was Covered and What Wasn’t

Real-world examples provide valuable insights into how pet insurance actually works in practice:

Emergency Surgery Scenarios

Case Study: Tucker’s Foreign Body Obstruction

Incident: 3-year-old Labrador Retriever ingested a sock
Treatment: Emergency endoscopy and surgical removal
Total bill: $3,800
Insurance details: $250 deductible, 90% reimbursement
Coverage outcome: $3,195 reimbursed ($3,800 – $250 deductible = $3,550 × 90%)
Why it was covered: Accident coverage for foreign body ingestion, a common and typically covered emergency

Case Study: Stella’s Cruciate Ligament Tear

Incident: 5-year-old Mixed Breed dog tore her ACL during play
Treatment: TPLO surgery and rehabilitation
Total bill: $5,200
Insurance details: $500 deductible, 80% reimbursement
Coverage outcome: Denied due to 6-month orthopedic waiting period not being satisfied
Prevention lesson: Understand specific waiting periods for orthopedic conditions, which are often longer than standard illness waiting periods

Cancer Treatment Coverage

Case Study: Max’s Lymphoma

Incident: 8-year-old Golden Retriever diagnosed with lymphoma
Treatment: Chemotherapy protocol over 6 months
Total bill: $12,000
Insurance details: $1,000 annual deductible, 90% reimbursement, unlimited annual maximum
Coverage outcome: $9,900 reimbursed ($12,000 – $1,000 = $11,000 × 90%)
Why it was covered: Illness diagnosed after policy waiting periods, with no pre-existing symptoms

Case Study: Bella’s Mast Cell Tumor

Incident: 7-year-old Boxer diagnosed with mast cell tumor
Treatment: Surgery and follow-up treatment
Total bill: $4,500
Insurance details: $250 deductible, 80% reimbursement
Coverage outcome: Partial coverage ($2,400) with exclusion of some treatments considered “experimental”
Lesson learned: Some cutting-edge treatments may not be covered under standard policies

Chronic Condition Management

Case Study: Charlie’s Diabetes

Incident: 6-year-old Domestic Shorthair cat diagnosed with diabetes
Treatment: Ongoing insulin, specialized diet, regular testing
Annual cost: Approximately $2,400
Insurance details: $200 annual deductible, 80% reimbursement
Coverage outcome: Approximately $1,760 reimbursed annually for testing and insulin (prescription food excluded)
Note: Coverage continued year after year as policy remained in force without lapse

Case Study: Luna’s Allergies

Incident: 4-year-old French Bulldog with severe skin allergies
Treatment: Allergy testing, immunotherapy, medications
Annual cost: Approximately $3,000
Insurance details: $500 deductible, 90% reimbursement
Coverage outcome: $2,250 reimbursed annually
Why it was covered: Condition developed after policy inception with no pre-existing symptoms

Denied Claims and Lessons Learned

Case Study: Oscar’s Pre-existing Heart Murmur

Incident: 5-year-old Maine Coon with heart failure requiring treatment
Treatment: Echocardiogram, medications, monitoring
Total bill: $2,800
Insurance details: $300 deductible, 80% reimbursement
Coverage outcome: Denied entirely as medical records showed a heart murmur was noted before policy inception
Lesson learned: Even mild symptoms or findings documented before enrollment can lead to related conditions being considered pre-existing

Case Study: Daisy’s Bilateral Condition

Incident: 4-year-old Pomeranian treated for luxating patella in right knee, then developed same condition in left knee 8 months later
Treatment: Surgical repair for both knees
Total bill: $3,200 (right knee), $3,400 (left knee)
Insurance details: $250 deductible, 90% reimbursement
Coverage outcome: Right knee covered ($2,655 reimbursed), left knee denied as bilateral exclusion
Lesson learned: Many policies contain bilateral condition clauses where a condition affecting one side of the body (hip, knee, ear, eye) is considered pre-existing for the opposite side

Actual Reimbursement Timelines and Processes

Digital-First Providers:

Lemonade: 2-3 business days for digital claims with complete documentation
Healthy Paws: 7-10 days average processing time
Embrace: 10-15 business days for most claims

Traditional Providers:

Nationwide: 14-21 days average processing time
ASPCA: 14-16 days average
Trupanion: Direct-pay to veterinarians when available; otherwise 14-20 days

Factors affecting processing times include:

Completeness of submitted documentation
Whether medical record review is required
Complexity of the claim
First-time claims vs. subsequent claims
Digital vs. paper submission methods

Most providers offer digital claim submission through mobile apps or online portals, significantly speeding up the process compared to mail-in claims.

How to Read and Compare Policy Documents

The details that matter most are often found in the fine print of policy documents. Here’s how to evaluate them effectively:

Deciphering the Fine Print

Policy documents contain several key sections to review carefully:

Coverage Section:

List of covered conditions and treatments
Coverage limits and sublimits for specific conditions
How coverage is calculated and applied
Special provisions for certain treatments

Exclusions Section:

Pre-existing condition definitions and determination process
Specific excluded conditions or treatments
Waiting period details and exceptions
Breed-specific exclusions or limitations

Claims Section:

Required documentation for claims
Submission deadlines and methods
Appeals process for denied claims
Reimbursement calculation examples

Definitions Section:

How the provider defines critical terms like “accident,” “illness,” and “pre-existing”
Medical terminology clarifications
Time-related definitions (e.g., policy period, waiting periods)

When comparing policies, create a spreadsheet with each provider’s approach to these key areas. Don’t rely solely on marketing materials—always review the actual policy document, typically available as a sample on the provider’s website.

Questions to Ask Before Purchasing

Before finalizing your policy choice, get answers to these essential questions:

About Coverage:

“How do you determine if a condition is pre-existing?”
“Do you cover hereditary and congenital conditions?”
“Is there a waiting period for orthopedic conditions? How long?”
“Are exam fees covered or just treatments?”
“Is there an age when coverage will decrease or premiums will significantly increase?”

About Claims:

“What documentation is required for claims?”
“What is your average claim processing time?”
“Do you require a veterinary examination before enrollment?”
“Do you review medical records for all claims or only certain types?”

About Costs:

“Do premiums increase with age? At what rate?”
“Do premiums increase after filing claims?”
“Are there discounts for multiple pets or paying annually?”
“What happens to coverage if I miss a payment?”

Record the answers to these questions for each provider you’re considering, preferably in writing or email. This documentation can be valuable if coverage disputes arise later.

Red Flags to Watch For in Policy Language

Be alert for these warning signs in policy documentation:

Vague Pre-existing Condition Language:

Look for clear definitions of how pre-existing conditions are determined
Be wary of language suggesting “signs or symptoms” rather than diagnosed conditions
Watch for broad discretion in determining what’s related to pre-existing conditions

Restrictive Payout Schedules:

Some policies use benefit schedules with fixed payouts for procedures
These often pay significantly less than percentage-based reimbursement
Check if reimbursement is based on actual costs or “usual and customary” fees

Broad Exclusion Categories:

Watch for exclusions covering entire body systems rather than specific conditions
Be cautious of policies excluding “developmental conditions” without clear definitions
Check for behavioral condition exclusions if relevant to your pet

Minimum Age Requirements for Certain Conditions:

Some policies don’t cover specific conditions until pets reach certain ages
This is particularly common for orthopedic conditions in large breed dogs
Look for stipulations about hip dysplasia coverage age minimums

Burdensome Documentation Requirements:

Policies requiring annual health certifications to maintain coverage
Requirements for specialized diagnostics to confirm conditions
Unusually short claim filing deadlines (less than 90 days)

If you notice these red flags, ask direct questions about how they would apply in specific scenarios relevant to your pet’s breed and age.

Coverage Verification Before Treatment

For planned procedures or when faced with significant treatment decisions:

Contact your insurer first: Before proceeding with expensive treatments, contact your insurance provider to verify coverage
Request pre-authorization: Many providers offer pre-approval for planned procedures
Get coverage confirmation in writing: Request email confirmation of coverage details
Clarify required documentation: Understand exactly what your veterinarian needs to provide
Ask about specific exclusions: Confirm if any aspects of the planned treatment would not be covered
Verify waiting period status: Ensure all relevant waiting periods have been satisfied

This proactive approach can prevent surprise claim denials and give you peace of mind when making treatment decisions.

The Claim Filing Process

Understanding how to properly file claims can significantly improve your reimbursement experience:

Documentation Required

Most insurance providers require these documents for claims:

Essential Documentation:

Completed claim form (paper or digital)
Itemized invoice showing all charges
Proof of payment to the veterinarian
Veterinary medical records relevant to the condition
Diagnosis and procedure codes (if available)

Sometimes Required:

Prior medical history for first-time claims
Laboratory and test results
Diagnostic imaging reports
Referral documentation for specialist visits
Prescription details for medication claims

Keep all veterinary documentation organized from the moment you enroll in insurance. Many claim issues stem from incomplete or inconsistent medical records.

Submission Methods and Timelines

Most providers offer multiple submission options:

Digital Submission:

Mobile app with photo/scan capabilities
Online portal upload
Email attachment
Typically processed faster than paper claims

Traditional Submission:

Fax
Mail
Often results in longer processing times

Submission Deadlines:

Most providers require submission within 60-180 days of treatment
Some have shorter windows for specific conditions
Late submissions are typically denied regardless of merit

Submit claims as soon as possible after treatment. Digital submissions generally result in faster processing and create a clear timestamp of your submission date.

Tracking and Following Up

Maintain organized records of your claim submissions:

Record submission dates, claim numbers, and confirmation notices
Check claim status through provider portals or apps after the expected processing time
If a claim is taking longer than the stated processing time, follow up proactively
Keep copies of all submitted documents and correspondence
Note the names of representatives you speak with about claims
Set calendar reminders for follow-up if claims aren’t resolved in the expected timeframe

Most providers have online systems for tracking claim status. Familiarize yourself with these tools before you need to submit your first claim.

Appealing Denied Claims Successfully

If your claim is denied, you have options:

Review the denial reason carefully: Understanding exactly why the claim was denied is crucial
Gather supporting documentation: Medical records, additional veterinary statements, or clarifications
Submit a formal appeal: Follow the provider’s specific appeal process
Provide new information: Include any relevant information that might not have been considered initially
Ask your veterinarian for help: A letter from your vet explaining the condition can be valuable
Be persistent but professional: Many initially denied claims are approved on appeal

Insurance providers typically have a formal appeals process outlined in your policy documents. Success rates for appeals with additional supporting documentation are surprisingly high, so don’t give up after an initial denial if you believe the claim should be covered.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is pet insurance worth it for healthy pets?

Pet insurance provides the most value when purchased while pets are still healthy, before they develop any pre-existing conditions. Young, healthy pets have the lowest premiums and fewest exclusions. Think of pet insurance as protection against unexpected future conditions rather than for existing health issues.

Statistics show that 1 in 3 pets will experience an emergency situation each year, with average costs ranging from $800-1,500. For serious conditions like cancer or orthopedic issues, costs can easily exceed $10,000. Insurance provides financial protection against these unpredictable expenses.

Can I change plans if my pet develops a condition?

Once your pet develops a medical condition, that condition will be considered pre-existing if you switch to a new insurance provider or plan. This means:

You can switch plans, but the existing condition won’t be covered under the new policy
It’s generally best to select a comprehensive plan from the start
If you must switch, do so before any symptoms develop
Some providers offer plan upgrades within their own company that may maintain coverage for existing conditions

If you’re considering switching providers, review your current policy for portability options or continuous coverage provisions, but these are rare in the pet insurance industry.

How do reimbursements work in practice?

The reimbursement process follows these typical steps:

You pay your veterinarian directly at the time of service
You submit your claim with all required documentation
The insurer reviews your claim against your policy terms
If approved, the calculation works as follows:
- Eligible expenses are determined (excluding non-covered items)
- Your annual deductible is subtracted (if not already met for the year)
- The reimbursement percentage (70%, 80%, 90%, etc.) is applied to the remaining amount
- The resulting figure is your reimbursement, subject to any annual limits

Example: For a $2,000 treatment with a $250 deductible and 80% reimbursement:

$2,000 eligible expenses – $250 deductible = $1,750
$1,750 × 80% = $1,400 reimbursement

Most providers offer direct deposit for faster reimbursement, though some still issue paper checks. Reimbursement typically arrives within 2-3 weeks of claim approval, though some digital-first providers have shortened this to a few days.

Why do premiums increase over time?

Pet insurance premiums typically increase for several reasons:

Age-Related Increases:

Pets face higher health risks as they age
Most providers increase premiums with each policy renewal to reflect increased risk
Senior pets (7+ years) often see steeper annual increases

Industry-Wide Factors:

Rising veterinary costs (increasing at 5-10% annually in most markets)
Advances in veterinary technology making more treatments possible but more expensive
Inflation and general economic factors

Individual Policy Factors:

Some providers raise rates based on claim history
Regional adjustments based on local veterinary costs
Breed-specific adjustments based on emerging health trends

On average, expect premium increases of 5-20% annually, with higher increases for older pets. Some providers are more transparent about their increase schedules than others, so ask about historical rate increases before enrolling.

Does coverage differ for dogs versus cats?

Yes, there are several key differences in insurance coverage between dogs and cats:

Premium Differences:

Cat insurance typically costs 40-60% less than dog insurance
The average monthly premium for cats is $25-35, while dogs average $40-60

Coverage Structure:

Core coverages (accidents, illnesses) are generally similar
Cats have fewer breed-specific exclusions
Dogs often have longer waiting periods for orthopedic conditions
Some providers offer cat-specific plans with coverage tailored to feline health issues

Common Exclusions:

Dogs: Hip dysplasia, cruciate ligament issues often have specific limitations
Cats: Dental disease, urinary conditions sometimes have specific provisions

Wellness Coverage:

Dog wellness plans often include parasite prevention, which is more costly for dogs
Cat wellness plans may emphasize dental care and indoor-specific preventive measures

When shopping for coverage, look for providers with species-specific plans rather than one-size-fits-all approaches, as they tend to offer more tailored coverage and better value.

Conclusion: Making an Informed Pet Insurance Decision

Navigating pet insurance options requires balancing multiple factors: coverage breadth, cost, your pet’s specific needs, and your financial circumstances. Here are the key takeaways to guide your decision:

Start Early: The best time to insure your pet is when they’re young and healthy, before any conditions develop that would be considered pre-existing.

Match Coverage to Risk: Consider your pet’s breed, age, lifestyle, and environment when selecting coverage. Different pets have vastly different risk profiles and insurance needs.

Focus on Catastrophic Coverage: At minimum, ensure your policy would protect you from financial hardship in worst-case scenarios like cancer treatment, emergency surgery, or chronic condition management.

Read the Fine Print: Policy details matter enormously. Take time to understand waiting periods, exclusions, reimbursement methods, and claim requirements before enrolling.

Consider Lifetime Costs: Factor in premium increases over your pet’s lifetime, not just the initial rate. A policy that seems affordable today may become unsustainable as your pet ages.

Don’t Overinsure: Wellness coverage and add-ons can be valuable but may not be cost-effective for everyone. Calculate whether the additional premium outweighs the expected routine care costs.

Verify Provider Reputation: Research customer reviews focusing specifically on claims experiences and customer service during difficult situations. The true test of insurance is how it performs when needed most.

Pet insurance is ultimately about peace of mind—knowing you won’t have to choose between financial stability and your pet’s health. The right policy allows you to make medical decisions based on what’s best for your pet rather than what you can afford in the moment.

We’d love to hear about your experiences with pet insurance or answer any questions you might have about coverage options. Share your thoughts in the comments below!

This article was last updated on May 1, 2025, to reflect current market offerings and policy trends. While we strive for accuracy, always verify specific coverage details directly with insurance providers before purchasing a policy.

Table of Contents